www.youtube.com
STOP Using Clerk Auth : here is WHY (nobody talk about that)
Excerpt
### Transcript {ts:0} Why you should stop using Clerk right now. I'm pretty bullish about Clerk {ts:6} since it's been released and I really think it's a big mistake to use this tool right now, especially since the IIA {ts:15} area arrived, especially since the AI area arrived. So let's deep why you should not use clerk together. So I make {ts:26} main five six points as we have just here. So what is the first point? Authentification is the core of your {ts:36} application. O defines your apps architecture. Why you should delegate the most important part of your app to a {ts:46} company that you don't control? Because what you actually delegating first user data credential session metadata all on {ts:55} day server you don't own the data anymore second app architecture your middleware roots components depends now {ts:64} on clerk SDK so a migration cost a lot business continuity if cler change pricing pivot or die you're stuck okay {ts:74} because all your app depends on this tool so now you to continue to use clerk because all of this view all of these {ts:82} components use clerk security model. So this is one good argument for clerk for big company that doesn't want to look {ts:92} like they handle everything on their own. Clerk have a really good security. So this is one good argument and you {ts:100} have the user experience pre-built components. What happened? You get the great lock in again password are not {ts:107} exportable in plain text all user sation terminate everyone must relog if you migrate use o cler provider middle {ts:114} weight you need to rewrite everything so here it's a bit [ __ ] but the main point is do you want to delegate {ts:122} authentification because few months ago there is a sense to {ts:128} delegate this because it was boring to rebuild the UI again and again and again but Now in this area is this worse to do … {ts:372} why why you need to pay for user? What is the reason you would pay for any user in your app? It's no sense. Like I just {ts:384} don't understand why anyone would use this tool. So {ts:390} what you have here when you pay is then you have a lot of upsell. … {ts:522} Okay, I don't understand. Uh so here we have the bing. ... Like basically it's stripe and they are like {ts:531} okay stripe is already a good software. Let's add the fees on top of it. All of this to add you shitty feature that code {ts:539} can vibe code in less than three second, right? Like clo vood this billing software in less than 3 seconds. But {ts:546} they will charge each of your user 0.7%. 0.7%. Is this insane? Yes, it's insane. Okay, … So we add more feature and we {ts:600} pay wall some of our previously free feature or we add re feature that our user require request {ts:609} and we basically put a price on it. phase three extract pred predatory pricing vendor locking assume so they {ts:617} will print money cla is a company that lose money for sure I don't know actually verify this information I think {ts:624} so for example o zero raised massive here is what happened cla is the same trajectory so we have just here {ts:633} then technical problem clarness gs is not optimized 50% of your app bundle it's a lot of [ __ ] so clerk creates {ts:642} some latency. I I have no I I didn't try it. Okay, so take this with a some salt. Okay, it's okay. Community Exod Why do {ts:652} you think CL pricing is predatory though? So they asked this directly to Cler founder. The typical CL developer {ts:660} journey months one to six cler is amazing. Months 12 the pricing month they send months 18 locked in or {ts:668} switched. So uh when we eat 50k user cler quest 5,000 a month switch to better o in two weeks save 50,000 a year {ts:678} sation terminate randomly user locked out for no reason super say noun issue $100 a month surprise at an image me
Related Pain Points
v0 Service Reliability and Data Loss
9v0 experiences frequent service outages, request processing failures, and data loss issues including deleted conversations, disappearing messages, and erased deployments. Users report being unable to rely on the tool for production work despite paying subscription fees.
Vendor Lock-in via Proprietary Agent and Ecosystem
7Datadog's proprietary agent tightly couples applications to its ecosystem. While it accepts OpenTelemetry, advanced APM features still require the proprietary agent. Migration away requires complete re-instrumentation, and rebuilding dashboards, alerts, and data pipelines from scratch.
Prohibitive pricing structure for small developers
6Gemini API pricing starts at $99/month for basic features with additional per-request costs that scale steeply with usage. For solo developers and small teams, production-scale usage becomes financially unviable. Competing APIs offer better value propositions.
Immature Billing Integration
5Clerk's billing integration with payment providers exists but remains immature and underdeveloped. The integration adds a markup (0.7%) on top of Stripe charges for minimal value, representing a "shitty feature" that could be coded in seconds.